Context UKDI UK

UK Defence Innovation: competition assessment process and criteria (guidance)

At a glance

Instrument
Context
Application route
grant application

Eligibility

Open to innovators submitting via the UKDI online submission service; competition-specific eligibility and TRL bands set in each competition document.

Why it matters

Codifies the exact sift and scoring logic behind every UKDI/DASA competition, including hard non-compliance traps (answers in attachments, wrong TRL, no acceptance of T&Cs). Relevant to any UK-based or UK-present defence-tech firm or bid consultancy preparing UKDI submissions.

Do this:

Join the UKDI mailing list and register on the UKDI online submission service, then rewrite your standard bid template around the desirable/feasible/viable criteria and word limits before the next themed competition opens.

Summary

UKDI (incorporating the former DASA) sets out its 10-stage competition process from launch on the UKDI Competition Services page through online submission, pre-sift, assessment, moderation, challenge, decision conference, decision and feedback release. All proposals are assessed against three baseline criteria, desirable (strategic fit, user pull), feasible (technical credibility, ambition, team expertise) and viable (project delivery, value for money). Unfunded but fundable proposals remain considered fundable for 12 months and may be shared with other UK government funders.

Dates in this notice

  1. Published

Organisations in this notice

This noticeContext

Source & methodology

Source: https://www.gov.uk/guidance/assessment-process-and-criteria, summarised by Rearm Radar. Check the details at the source before bidding.

AI-extracted summary (claude-opus-5). confidence 90%.

Source text (original language, not translated)
This guidance explains our competition process and how your proposal is assessed.

At
UKDI
, we have a very thorough process for deciding which proposals to fund. The below guidance sets out our full competition process including the guidance given to our assessors to assess proposals.
Competition process
The competition process is made up of 10 stages.
1. Competition opens
All competitions are launched on our
UKDI
Competition Services
page.
Sign up to the
UKDI
Mailing List
Be the first to hear about new competitions, upcoming events and other
UKDI
news. To join the
UKDI
Mailing List, please complete the short sign up form
here
2. Proposal submission
The only way to submit a proposal to
UKDI
is online via the
UKDI
online submission service.
Log in or register for an account
.
Some tips to help with your submission:
before submitting your proposal, check the terms and conditions carefully to ensure that you agree with all of them. You may wish to check them with your commercial or legal department. Please read the Open Call
terms and conditions here
. The terms and conditions for a themed competition can be found within the competition document.
draft your proposal offline to avoid losing material when submitting online
be concise. Each assessor should be able to read, understand and assess your proposal within 1 hour and 30 minutes, unless otherwise stated in the competition document. Use the text boxes provided in the application form and look out for the word limits
attachments are limited to .png, .jpg, or.jpeg files only. Please provide full answers on the (Desirable/Feasible/Viable) criteria for your Innovation in the boxes provided. Proposals received with Desirable/Feasible/Viable answers provided as attachments will be considered non-compliant and sifted out of the competition.
only click submit when your proposal is complete. It is not possible to add any additional information to your proposal after it has been submitted
innovators are strongly advised to submit their proposal at least one hour before the deadline stated on the competition document. Proposals submitted close to the deadline risk encountering issues that cannot be resolved in time. Responsibility for timely submission rests entirely with the innovator, no extensions will be made.
3. Competition close
4. Pre sift
Once you have submitted your proposal, it will pass through an initial pre-sift process. At this stage, your proposal may be rejected if it:
does not demonstrate impact for defence or security
does not outline how it meets the scope of the competition
is incomplete
if the attachments have been used for additional text data over the stated word counts in Desirability, Feasibility, Viability and Additional Information
is lacking technical information to allow technical assessment to take place
does not demonstrate how the project can be completed in the timelines
exceeds the funding limit or timescale stipulated
does not demonstrate acceptance of or comply with
UKDI
terms and conditions
is not at the correct Technology Readiness Level (
TRL
) for the competition
is a resubmission of a previous proposal and does not adhere to the
resubmission guidelines
Further guidance on pre sift criteria is described in the online submission service for the specific competition and in the relevant competition document, accessible via the
UKDI
Competition Services
page.
5. Assessment
After the initial sifting process, experts from across UK government will be assigned to assess your proposal. When people outside of UK Government are used for assessment, it will be under a non-disclosure agreement and details will be provided in advance in the relevant competition document.
During the assessment phase all proposals are assessed against the following criteria:
desirable: strategic fit, end user support/pull (letters of support not required)
feasible: technical credibility, innovation, risk, expertise of team/capability
viable: costs and value for money, project delivery/plan
Further guidance on
assessment criteria is listed below
.
6. Moderation
After assessment, a moderator will compile an overview, pulling together comments to provide a collective outcome in the form of a ‘Fund’ or ‘No Fund’ recommendation against the proposal.
7. Challenge
Stakeholders/moderators are invited to challenge the ‘Fund’ or ‘No Fund recommendation made against each proposal. Challengers present their argument both in written form for circulation and at the decision conference.
8. Decision conference
The decision conference brings key stakeholders together to review proposal recommendations in line with competition delivery, including challenged recommendations. The moderator comments are presented and any challenges reviewed. At the conclusion of the conference, a final decision is made on whether each proposal will be funded.
Innovators are not permitted to attend.
9. Decision release
You’ll be able to track the progress of your application on your dashboard. You’ll be notified by email when we’ve made a decision on whether or not to fund your proposal.
If you are successful, our commercial team will be in touch shortly after the decision date to begin contracting. Once you are on contract, both
UKDI
staff and a Technical Partner will support and advise you throughout the period of your project.
10. Feedback release
If you are unsuccessful, you will receive brief written feedback within a few weeks of the applicable decision date. Feedback will be made available to you via email. Feedback is prepared by the proposal moderator, and is based on comments from all assessors and discussions at the decision conference. The feedback will give the main reasons why your proposal was unsuccessful.
Please note that every
UKDI
competition has a finite financial limit which affects the number of bids we can fund. Where a proposal meets the fundable requirements for a competition, but is not funded,
UKDI
will continue to seek funding and shall consider your proposal fundable for 12 months from the date of the feedback release.
We will share the abstract, Proposal Value Proposition Statement (PVPS) and title of your proposal with partners across His Majesty’s Government that may express an interest in funding the proposal through
UKDI
, in accordance with the competition document. We may also share this information on our cross-government Ideas Marketplace platform to foster collaboration and attempt to elicit funding. If partners across His Majesty’s Government wish to read the full proposal to decide if they will fund it, we will share the full proposal with them without seeking your permission if it is within 60 days of the feedback release date. If it is over 60 days since the feedback release date we will seek your permission before sharing the full proposal with them.
For other potential funders, we will seek your permission before sharing the full proposal regardless of the number of days since the feedback release date.
In the event that additional funding becomes available,
UKDI
may ask whether you would still be prepared to undertake the work outlined in your proposal under the same terms. Your official
UKDI
feedback will indicate if your proposal was deemed fundable, but not awarded funding at the time.
Assessment criteria
UKDI
uses three baseline assessment criteria; desirable, feasible and viable. The baseline criteria apply to all our competitions, unless stated in the competition document. It is important to note that criteria may be adjusted across competitions in accordance with the needs of Government customers, any criteria changes will be clearly detailed within the competition document. You should check the specific guidance that is provided within the competition document on the
UKDI
Competition Services
page.
Once the criteria have been published for a particular competition, they will remain frozen for the duration of that competition.
Corresponding guidance on what we need to see in the various sections of your proposal is provided in the proposal template on our on-line submission service.
In order to give you the best chance of success, please find below guidance on the three baseline criteria that is provided to our assessors in order to assess your proposals.
Desirable
UKDI
funds innovations that solve defence and security challenges. You should look out for things like the proposal’s alignment with a strategic need or challenge and who would benefit from the innovation. Ideas that are useful for both defence and security should be acknowledged.
Under this category, proposals should be assessed on:
Strategic fit
the proposal explains how the idea is innovative and is clear on the business need, technological challenge or market opportunity driving the innovation
the proposal identifies who in defence and/or security might benefit from and exploit the innovation if successful
the proposal has a clear link to a user need or challenge. This may be the challenge as specified in the competition document
Defence and security compatibility
the proposal outlines how the proposers idea is different to any current solutions
the proposal shows benefit across defence and/or security sectors
the proposal describes the impact for defence and/or security in terms of performance, time and cost
Exploitation beyond the Project Plan
the proposal outlines how the proposer expects to take the solution to market on completion of the project and who the appropriate partners would be to do so. This may include information on further phases of development or funding required for the solution to reach an appropriate
Technology Readiness Level (
TRL
)
for procurement
Feasible
You should assess whether the idea has a good chance of success technically.
You are asked to consider whether the proposal is scientifically, technically and practically feasible, how innovative the idea is, and how it compares with potential alternatives. A clear and logical plan, backed by relevant expertise, capability and appropriate resources needs to be present.
Under this category, proposals should be assessed on:
Technical Credibility
the proposal is scientifically, technically and practically feasible
the proposal has a robust testing regime with clear and quantifiable measures of progress and performance
Ambition, challenge and advantage
the proposal outlines how the Innovator will undertake the work, their plans to address the challenges related to that work, how challenging and ambitious their approach is and what advantages the solution offers to the customer / stakeholder / end-user.
Expertise and capability
the proposal provides evidence of the team’s relevant expertise and experience in the technical area of the innovation, including background research and projects completed
the proposal provides evidence of the resources available to the team to deliver the project including facilities and labour
Viable
You should assess for evidence that the idea can be delivered within the project scope and timelines.
Look for evidence of a robust project plan which identifies any links or dependencies between work packages and milestones, and which clearly identifies measurable deliverables. We are looking at overall costs and value for money. Finally, please look at the proposer’s plans to take their innovation forward beyond the project.
Under this category, proposals should be assessed on:
Project Delivery
the proposal has a project plan in sufficient detail and identifies any links or dependencies between work packages and/or milestones
the proposal identifies any project risks or dependencies and has identified appropriate mitigations
the proposal identifies any need for Government Furnished Assets (
GFA
) (including Government Furnished Information (GFI)). Should
GFA
not be granted, the proposal identifies suitable alternatives
the proposal identifies any
legal or ethical concerns including MODREC approval, RIPA, data protection
and has put in place appropriate steps and timescales to heed these considerations
Value for Money:
the propo